Canadian Rail Stoppage: Will the Agricultural Industry in Canada and the U.S. go off the rails?

August 22, 2024

Josh McClure

Chicago, IL —In an unprecedented move, Canada’s two primary railroad operators, Canadian National Railway (CNR) and Canadian Pacific Kansas City (CPKC), have locked out over 9,000 employees following a breakdown in labor negotiations with the Teamsters Canada Rail Conference. The lockout, which took effect at 12:01 a.m. Eastern time on August 22, threatens to severely disrupt the transportation of goods across North America, with the agricultural sector among the hardest hit.

The Stoppage

The simultaneous lockout by CNR and CPKC is poised to create significant upheaval across North American supply chains. The Canadian Chamber of Commerce has estimated that the stoppage will disrupt the flow of approximately $730 million in goods each day, with cross-border trade and domestic logistics expected to suffer substantial setbacks.

Agriculture is particularly vulnerable to the disruption, as both Canada and the U.S. rely heavily on rail transportation for the movement of bulk commodities such as grains, oilseeds, and fertilizers. Canada, the world’s fifth-largest exporter of wheat and the top exporter of canola, stands to lose millions in revenue each day that the rail network remains inactive.

Impact on the Canadian Ag producers

The Canadian agricultural industry is bracing for significant challenges as the rail stoppage unfolds. Rail transport is critical during the harvest season, when large volumes of grains and oilseeds must be moved from farms to export terminals. With the rail network crippled, farmers are likely to face significant delays in getting their crops to market.

“Canadian farmers depend on a reliable rail system to move their crops, especially during the critical harvest season. This stoppage could be devastating,” said a spokesperson for the Grain Growers of Canada. “If this lockout continues, we could see crops piling up at elevators with no means of transport, leading to significant financial losses.”

The stoppage is particularly concerning for the canola industry. Canada is the largest producer and exporter of canola, a crop that is crucial for both food and biofuel production globally. The inability to move canola to export terminals could lead to a significant backlog, depressing prices and damaging Canada’s reputation as a reliable supplier.

Moreover, the disruption in the supply of fertilizers and other agricultural inputs could have downstream effects, potentially affecting planting decisions for the next season. Farmers may face higher input costs and reduced availability of essential products, further compounding the economic impact.

Impact on the U.S. Ag producers

However, the impacts of the Canadian rail stoppage are not confined to Canada alone. The U.S. agricultural industry is likely to experience significant repercussions as well, particularly in the northern states where U.S. supply chains are closely intertwined with Canada’s.

The U.S. exports a substantial amount of corn, soybeans, and other grains to Canada, much of which travels by rail. With the rail network disrupted, these exports could face significant delays, reducing U.S. farmers' access to a key market. Additionally, the movement of U.S. agricultural products to ports on the Pacific Northwest, which often transits through Canada, is likely to be severely hampered.

"The Canadian rail stoppage is a major concern for U.S. agriculture, especially for states like North Dakota and Minnesota, which rely heavily on rail transport for their grain exports," said an analyst from the U.S. Grains Council. "If this situation isn’t resolved quickly, we could see a backlog of U.S. grains and soybeans, leading to storage issues and potential price declines."

Long-Term Implications and Industry Response

The long-term implications of the rail stoppage could be profound, particularly if the lockout continues for an extended period. The Canadian government has so far declined to intervene in the labor dispute, adding to the uncertainty surrounding its resolution.

In the meantime, Canadian and U.S. agricultural stakeholders are scrambling to find alternative transportation methods. However, trucking and other forms of transport are unlikely to fully compensate for the loss of rail capacity, especially for bulk commodities that are typically moved in large quantities by train.

The situation also highlights vulnerabilities in the North American agricultural supply chain, particularly its dependence on rail infrastructure. Industry groups in both countries are calling for contingency plans and greater investment in alternative logistics solutions to mitigate the risk of future disruptions.

As the Canadian rail stoppage continues, the agricultural industries in both Canada and the U.S. face mounting challenges. The disruption threatens to derail the timely transport of key commodities, leading to economic losses, supply chain delays, and potential long-term consequences for farmers and exporters. With no immediate resolution in sight, the situation remains a critical concern for the agricultural sector on both sides of the border.

Disclaimer:

FBN Market Advisory services are offered by FBN BR LLC - NFA ID: 0508695. Commodity trading, including futures, hedging, and speculating, involves substantial risk of loss and may not be suitable for all investors. All information, publications, and reports, including this specific material, used and distributed by FBN BR LLC shall be construed as a solicitation. The information and data provided come from sources believed to be reliable but FBN BR LLC does not guarantee its accuracy or completeness. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.